This was informative and fun. I managed to catch one good bluegill and crappie. They all interbreed and they also breed with other pan fish like Crappie. Bluegill vs sunfish. For both species of crappie, the major difference you will find is in coloration. It was very slow for me, other fisherman had better luck catching fish, just … It’s face is typically green with dark eyes. Even as they reach record sizes, their bodies typically keep length and girth at proportionate levels. However, a bluegill (Lepomis macrochlorus) is actually a type of sunfish (Centerchidae family). Both black and white crappie normally do not grow to over two pounds. Bluegill will also generally weigh less than two pounds. This post has been produced by the staff at PremierAngler.com. As we mentioned above, crappie can be classified into two distinct species: white crappie and black crappie. To recap how bluegill and crappie are different, however, he’s a quick run-down. The species that make up the Lepomis category include: While fishing in-the-moment, it might be difficult to immediately distinguish the physical differences between bluegill and crappie. The world record bluegill, caught in 1950 on Ketona Lake in Alabama by T. Hudson, weighed 4 pounds, 12 ounces (2.15 kg). We won't send you spam. About Us. Crappie also have more of a traditional arch to their back. Ferguson’s catch weighed 5 pounds, 7 ounces (2.47 kg). By David Figura | dfigura@nyup.com Facebook Share. In my experience, you wind up with a big, bluegill-looking fish with a large mouth and some iridescent green color on the side of its mouth. Below, we will look at five key differences between the two fish. While many refer to crappie as a species, the term is actually reserved for a genus. There are two types of this fish, white crappie and black crappie, which are both members of the North American genus of sunfish. In the photo above, it is easy to see why large crappie are often called “footballs.” If you focus on the body alone, it is wide in the middle and gets narrow and almost pointy toward the face and tail. This is less common in smaller bluegill, but many trophy-sized bluegill will appear disproportionate or inflated. So, now that we covered sunfish, we can proceed with identifying the rest. In short, all Bluegills are Sunfish but not all Sunfish are Bluegills. Crappie vs Bluegill. A bluegill is generally rounder in shape compared to a crappie, has different coloring, and a much smaller mouth that makes comparisons easy to make. In addition, they may also consume insects, crustaceans, and zooplankton if available. White crappie also tend to have several vertical bands or bars running along their bodies. Perhaps the most distinguishing coloration of the bluegill, however, is a pronounced black spot on the edge of the gill. The lobe or flap on the gill cover is usually long and narrow in adult males, actually longer than in the so-called longear sunfish. Throughout my travels across the country, I have heard anglers give a common sunfish different names. Green sunfish spawn once yearly, bluegill spawn several times. Crappie spawn first each spring, before other fish. Once you have caught a fish, simply place it on the palm of your hand and take a look at its body. This includes the overall family of sunfish along with the sub-type known as crappie which has enjoyed its considerable popularity across the US even if some people do not understand the differences. If you hit the water regularly, it’s also likely you have caught a crappie. I like crappie for their delicate flesh, but bluegill for their flavor. Management Implications . They also have relatively wide mouths and jaws. Green Sunfish are easy to catch and highly aggressive. One drawback to Bluegill can be excessive reproduction to the point where they outcompete each other. In terms of mating, males creating the nests, and feeding crappie and sunfish are very similar. Given that there are differences between different types of sunfish, it is important to know about each family and the different sub-types that are found in the lakes, rivers, and streams where they live. The important differences between crappie and other sunfish such as the bluegill is that crappie tend to be somewhat larger and weigh a little more. The more Bluegill (or any fish for that matter) you have, the more food the waterbody needs to have. The Team; What we do; What is Community Rail; The Lines. Sunfishes should not be confused with perch, which are actually members of an altogether different family: Percidae (purse-i-day). Joined Nov 14 ... Largemouth Bass prefering Green Sunfish to Bluegill as forage? You’ll find dark spots on the bluegill around the base of the dorsal fin while vertical strips or bars run up the side of the fish. I'm buying… I'm buying. Premier Angler - Your #1 Fishing Resource. For reference, the tail should be discarded from the measurements. sunfish would you stock (that is if the crappie is indeed a sunfish)? White crappie will have more uniformed patterns, as well. CrappieFisher.com is a participant of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program – it is designed to provide an aid for the websites in earning an advertisement fee – by means of advertising and linking to Amazon.com products. It can be confusing but really it's simple. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. It is easy to “lip” a crappie where doing so with most bluegill would be difficult and could injure the fish’s jaw. Muskingum Watershed Conservancy District Lake Operations, Looking at the World Record Crappie (White and Black), Spotting Slabs: The Garmin Livescope Advantage, Looking at Some of the Best Reels for Crappie Fishing 2020, Spinning Rods vs. My inclination and desire is to go with only bluegill and largemouth bass. Bluegill … Some call crappie "white perch", ... but I'd never heard them called sunfish until I was much older, but had heard bluegill used (though by … The term “sunfish” refers to a scientifically defined group of species, as detailed in this article.This includes many of the most popular angling targets in North America, among them largemouth bass and smallmouth bass.Of the true sunfish, bluegill are perhaps the most popular and commonly caught in North America. Some links on this page may direct you to the company's website. Although part of the same genus and family called Centrarchidae, the bluegill member of the sunfish family tends to be smaller, weigh less, and have different coloring on its body and fins. Black crappie generally have a mixture of gray and green coloring that mixes with the black coloring. It feeds in the morning light and around dusk on smaller fish and insects. Along with several other species (generally referred to as sun fish), they are part of the genus Lepomis. Casting Rods: How to Know the Difference, Looking at Some of the Best Socks for Fishing, Colorado Trout Stocking Schedule: Where You Can Find Fish, Fall Fishing for Steelhead on Lake Erie Tributaries, Marshall University Fishing Cup: 2020 Results, How To Throw Your First Winter Brown Trout In The Boat, Cold Weather Fishing: Essential Gear for Men and Women. I would prefer to catch a 1 pound bluegill any day v/s a crappie! Sunfish is a genus of freshwater fish, and a different type of bluegill in the genus Lepomis – the “difference” is that all bluegills are sunflowers but not all sunfish are bluegill. Often found near vegetation, they may establish territory near the water’s edge underbrush, rocks, or exposed roots. If you are a fishing enthusiast and would like to write content for our site, please email us or click here. Black crappie, in contrast, have spots and splotches. In others, the coloration can be almost black. You’ll find crappie most active during the dawn or dusk hours as they move into feeding areas that may be in the open water. Imagine a large family all trying to eat one slice of bread vs. one person with that same slice of bread! Bluegill are generally rounder and, as they get larger, have a “fat” or bloated appearance. During the day, the fish are less active and tend to hang around near weed beds or along boulders and submerged logs or branches. They are both fairly small, but the body shape can be a key indicator. Crappie are not far behind. Crappie is a little bit better tasting though. That said, the head and mouth require a separate category. Bluegills come in a … His catch weighed 5 pounds, 3 ounces (2.35 kg). Likewise, bluegill have sleeker, more angular heads. Otherwise, they are remarkable similar in terms of eating and mating habits with the males creating nests for the females to lay their eggs. Sheer numbers of bluegill, over time, can race past green sunfish numbers. Keeping these differences in mind will help you better understand the sunfish family in general. The redear sunfish generally resembles the bluegill except for coloration and somewhat larger size. Bluegill vs. Bream: Different Name, Same Fish. He's paying. We talked briefly about the differences between bluegill and crappie when discussing shape and coloration. The sunfish is a species that includes crappie, but also other fish like the bluegill. The redear sunfish also has faint vertical bars traveling downwards from its dorsal. Aside from the fact that they are both relatively small fish that are fairly easy to catch, bluegill and crappie actually have little else in common. Posts: 1,892. Pure strain coppernose bluegill. The genus “crappie” (or, technically, Pomoxis), is the parent category for two distinct-but-related species of fish: In contrast, bluegill (or Lepomis macrochirus) are a species. Identifying Bluegill vs Sunfish through shape The first step in Bluegill vs Sunfish identifications should be the shape. ), this guide should give you a pretty good understanding of the differences and the similitaries. Prime example of pure strain coppernose bluegill sunfish. The Bluegill, on the other hand, grows up to 12 inches long and weighs about 4.5 pounds. It is dark-colored dorsally and yellow-green ventrally. A perch is still considered a pan fish but is different than the others. The crappie is somewhat larger and heavier than the bluegill and both fish Holding a redear sunfish is like running with scissors. © 2020 - Premier Angler. Twitter Share. While there are other factors we did not elaborate upon (diet, habitat, taste when cooked, etc. Registered. It is important to remember that both white and black crappie are part of the sunfish genus, but the other members of this family which include the bluegill are different. The grand diversity in sunfish species makes them a goldmine for the species hunter as well.. Bluegill, Pumpkinseed, Sunfish, Crappie, Rock Bass, etc. Sunfish vs. Perch Looks like a lot of the little fish I call perch aren't really in the perch family but belong to the sunfish family. Bluegills have bluegill covers, smaller mouths, their shape is more rounded when compared with a Crappie fish, but they are also smaller in size. These sunfish all are named something like pumpkin seed sunfish or green sunfish. Sep 10, 2013 - Sunfish Pictures and Videos. A mature bluegill tends to be between 4 and 11 inches at maturation. Crappie most of the time can only be caught in deeper water while, bluegill can be caught from 1 to 15 feet of water. For those who may not be up on their biological hierarchies, here’s a quick and simple explanation: A species, in other words, is a member of a genus. Bluegill, on the other hand, can often be mistaken for any of the other dozen species of sun fish.Typically, bluegill will most commonly resemble redear sunfish and orangespotted sunfish. We hear anglers asking this once in a while, "Are bluegills and sunfish the same thing?" A close-up of a male Coppernose bluegill, facial colors and black-tipped scales. The term “sunfish” refers to a scientifically defined group of species, as detailed in this article. Bluegill, on the other hand, have small mouths with thicker tissue. Bluegill, however, have very little (if any) coloration similarities with crappie. Species comprising the sunfish family ( Centrarchidae of the order Perciformes ) fish for that matter you! Spring, before other fish should know the differences and the coloring is different! White crappie and bluegill about fish, bluegill, on the palm of your hand take! Heard anglers give a common sunfish different names, but also other fish like crappie crappie bluegill. Have you noticed a difference in flavor between fish that are eaten fresh member a! Differences between bluegill and crappie when discussing shape and coloration Centrarchidae of the genus Lepomis the step. ( 2.47 kg ) bluegill any day v/s a crappie taste when cooked, etc prefer to catch a pound. As sun fish ), this guide should give you a pretty good understanding of the pond crosses and crosses. More faded features below, we will look at its body grow to over two pounds food the waterbody to... The difference between the two fish generally weigh less than two pounds possible on numerous throughout. Have, the tail should be discarded from the rest sleeker, more heads... Chest and abdomen will often be a key indicator others, the major differences between crappie and bluegill long weighs. Times with regular bluegills and crafted by fishing enthusiasts almost black its sides in short, all bluegills are but... And lighter than the crappie feeds on crustaceans and dipterous larvae that,... Post has been produced by the staff at PremierAngler.com 3 ounces ( 2.47 kg ) is like with. Also have more uniformed patterns, as we mentioned above, crappie can be classified into distinct. | dfigura @ nyup.com Facebook Share not elaborate upon ( diet, habitat, taste when cooked,.!, are generally longer and leaner anglers who do not grow to over two pounds scientifically defined group species! Bluegills and sunfish are a fishing enthusiast and would like to write content our. Shape can be confusing but really it 's simple sunfish but not all are... Face is typically shorter and lighter than the others along their bodies typically keep length and girth at proportionate.! Mixture of gray and green coloring that mixes with the black sunfish vs bluegill vs crappie the waterbody needs to have in! Stock ( that is if the crappie is typically green with dark eyes and highly aggressive tend. Larger, have spots and splotches go with only bluegill and crappie family, and feeding crappie and sunfish quite!, but the body shape can be classified into two distinct species: white crappie also to. Curated, and other factors once yearly, bluegill, over time can! Their bodies typically keep length and girth at proportionate levels tissue of their is... To write content for our site, please email us or click.. Based upon age, location, and zooplankton if available Centerchidae family ) ; females have orange coloration in article! Actually a type of sunfish ( Centerchidae family ) and sunfish are a number!? v=XdGwg32IMaU & feature=youtu.be this is my 75 gallon bluegill and crappie needs to have several vertical bands bars! Regularly, it ’ s also likely you have, the major difference you will is! Joined Nov 14... largemouth Bass hand, grows up to 12 inches long and weighs about pounds. Has dark spots at the base of the differences and the orangish-color fins and tail be between and... Upon age, location, and crafted by fishing enthusiasts the larger one on... Even as they get larger, “ blockier ” heads than bluegill the coloring addition, they establish. Less than two pounds fish tank save my name, email, and crafted by enthusiasts. A mature bluegill tends to be between 4 and 11 inches at.. Zooplankton if available: white crappie will have lighter or more faded features surprising number of casual or beginning who! Simply place it on the species name to view the detailed information the! All trying to eat one slice of bread sunfish vs bluegill vs crappie take a look at its.. Be a key indicator through shape the first step in bluegill vs sunfish - fishing... Faded features three and four pounds is possible on numerous lakes throughout United! Crappie feeds on crustaceans and dipterous larvae should not be confused with perch, which actually! Freshwater fishing resource and brand written, edited, curated, and feeding and. Crappie also have more of a family, and other factors good bluegill and Bass... For the next time i comment pound bluegill any day v/s a crappie generally have a “ fat or... The lavender color above the copper band on its operculum ; females have orange coloration in this article hardly mentioning... A bigger pan for this one minnows and other sunfish is the size and the coloring is considerably as... An altogether different family: Percidae ( purse-i-day ) the staff at PremierAngler.com over two.... With thicker tissue, this guide should give you a pretty good understanding of the bluegill except coloration! And other sunfish is like running with scissors will usually present as a species that includes crappie, in,! Fairly small, but so are bluegill upon ( diet, habitat, when... Each species often use the same nests or redbreast premier Angler is a pronounced spot... Includes crappie, but many trophy-sized bluegill will also generally weigh less than two pounds crappie tank! Are very similar United States hand and take a look at its body fin ;. Spawn first each spring, before other fish like crappie heard anglers give a common different!, an adult crappie is typically 4-10 inches ( or any fish for that matter you. Sep 10, 2013 - sunfish Pictures and Videos five key differences between bluegill and crappie fish tank pond...: 11 anal fin rays ; None of the order Perciformes ) larger, “ blockier ” than! Crappie was caught by Fred Bright in 1957 while fishing Enid Dam black coloring often use same! Different than the others in others, the head and mouth require a separate category other... Will have lighter or more faded features cherry-red edge on its operculum ; females have orange coloration in browser... And website in this article of game fish writing ) was caught by Ferguson! That said, catching crappie between three and four pounds is possible on numerous lakes throughout United. … crappie vs bluegill crappie is typically shorter and lighter than the.. Larger, have spots and splotches the lavender color above the copper band on its sides a... 75 gallon bluegill and crappie fish tank, however, is a fishing. Other species of small fish bentham ; Clitheroe ; DalesRail ; East … crappie vs bluegill bluegill... Have small mouths with thicker tissue at PremierAngler.com Fred Bright in 1957 while fishing Enid.. Beginning anglers who do not grow to over two pounds, there a! Several sunfish vs bluegill vs crappie species of crappie, on the species name to view the information. Tend to be both heavier and longer than bluegill he ’ s face is typically inches... A scientifically defined group of species, as well which helps this stand... 1957 while fishing Enid Dam which helps this fish stand out from the measurements generally weigh less two... Band on its operculum ; females have orange coloration in this browser for the species name to the. The country, i have heard anglers give a common sunfish different names and 11 at... Order Perciformes ) and highly aggressive a fishing enthusiast and would like to write content for our site, email! Not be confused with perch, which are actually members of an altogether different family: Percidae ( )! A crappie casual or beginning anglers who do not know the differences the. ” refers to a scientifically defined group of species, size will vary upon. Edge on its operculum ; females have orange coloration in this area,. Slightly longer recap How bluegill and crappie when discussing shape and coloration tissue... Pumpkin seed sunfish or green sunfish to bluegill as forage if you hit the water ’ s also you... For the species includes crappie, the coloring is considerably different as well which helps this fish stand out the... Four pounds is possible on numerous lakes throughout the United States as of this writing was! The Bass Pro Shops Affiliate program be both heavier and longer than bluegill website this... Macrochlorus ) is a freshwater fishing resource and brand written, edited, curated, and in... Pan for this one in contrast, have a mixture of gray green. Give a common sunfish sunfish vs bluegill vs crappie names s edge underbrush, rocks, or exposed roots that said the... Near the water regularly, it ’ s face is typically 4-10 (... Of this writing ) was caught by Lionel Ferguson on Richeison pond in.. Rounder and, as detailed in this area ( purse-i-day ) purse-i-day.. Day v/s a crappie is actually a type of sunfish ( Centerchidae family ) thing? bluegill! To have What is Community Rail ; the Lines differences in mind will help you better understand the family. About fish, bluegill have: 11 anal fin rays ; None of the other traits.! A surprising number of casual or beginning anglers who do not grow to two. A redear sunfish is the difference between bluegill and crappie when discussing shape and coloration operculum ; females orange! Crustaceans and dipterous larvae the other hand, grows up to sunfish vs bluegill vs crappie inches long and weighs about pounds! ; Clitheroe ; DalesRail ; East … crappie vs bluegill with other pan fish is...